A bachelorette party usually comes with a dress code, but Casey Church gave her bridesmaids a much more personal challenge. Instead of choosing a color or theme, she asked each woman to dress as the moment she first met the bride.
The result was a night filled with Girl Scouts, choir outfits, Disney accessories, a baby costume, and even a fake mustache.
The unusual idea brought together friends from different stages of Church’s life. Some had known her since childhood. Others became close during high school, college, or through TikTok.
Seeing those different friendships in one place made the celebration especially meaningful as Church prepares to marry her fiancé, Jake Grubbs, in November.
A Personal Dress Code
Church, a 30-year-old musician from Venice, Fla., found the idea on Pinterest. The theme immediately stood out because her friendships had started in very different ways.
“I met them in all different phases of my life,” Church tells PEOPLE. “Since I met them in all different ways I knew it would be a variety of fun and silly outfits!”
@caseychurchmusic so many seasons of life in one place 🥲🥲 also didn’t get a video of @MADISON FAITH which is ironic since we met bc of tiktok but she was wearing the same outfit as the day me met and I cried #bachelorette #bacheloretteparty ♬ I Knew It I Knew You Official Instrumental – Dan Swift Del Rey
The bachelorette celebration took place aboard Royal Caribbean’s Utopia of the Seas. The ship sailed to CocoCay and Nassau, Bahamas, giving the group a vacation setting for the weekend.
Church later shared a TikTok showing several of the bridesmaids in their carefully chosen outfits. She described the gathering as “so many seasons of life in one place.”
The theme did more than create funny photos. Each outfit represented a specific memory, allowing the group to revisit the beginning of friendships that had lasted for years.
Childhood Memories
Church’s younger sister, Alyssa, went back further than anyone else. Since she has known Church from birth, she dressed as a baby.
The choice reflected the sisters’ close relationship. Church says they have “always been best friends.”
Kaitlyn, Lisa, and Allison chose another childhood connection. The three women dressed as Girl Scouts to represent the elementary school troop where they first became friends with Church.
Their friendship included years of shared experiences, from community service projects to camping trips. Now, those same childhood friends were celebrating another major milestone together.
Church says they “joined the same troop in elementary school and have countless memories from community service to camping and now are celebrating big life milestones like this one.”
Tiffany used a high school memory for her outfit. She found a choir dress on Amazon that closely matched the clothing worn when she and Church first met.
Another bridesmaid, Amber, looked to college for inspiration. She recreated the setting where she and Church became friends: a local line dancing bar where the pair spent nights dancing together.
Madison B. chose an equally specific memory. Her outfit represented the first night she and Church spent together, when Church taught her how to perform the cup song.
The outfits were different, but each one had the same purpose. They showed how individual moments had developed into lasting friendships.
The Mustache Moment
Kristen had one of the most unexpected costumes of the night.
Church originally met Kristen through Kristen’s husband, who was already part of Church’s friend group. For the party, Kristen decided to dress as her husband.
She completed the look with a fake mustache and glasses. More importantly, she stayed in character for the entire evening.
“One of my personal favorite outfits was Kristen,” Church says. “Yes she wore the mustache and glasses the whole night lol.”
The simple costume became one of the night’s most memorable moments because Kristen fully committed to the joke.
A TikTok Friendship
One of the most emotional outfits came from Madison T., whom Church met through TikTok.
Church had posted Disney-related content online before connecting with Madison T. Their online friendship eventually moved into real life. The two first met in person at Magic Kingdom in June 2021.
For the bachelorette party, Madison recreated the exact outfit she wore that day. It included a yellow dress and Mickey ears.
The memory carried special meaning for Church because their friendship started on social media and eventually led to Madison becoming part of the wedding party.
Church says meeting Madison T. and another friend, Hailey, through TikTok “opened my eyes to the power of social media and not to be afraid to go out of your comfort zone because you might just meet some of your best friends!”
Madison arrived at a different time than the other women, so Church did not capture her entrance in the TikTok video. Still, seeing the familiar yellow dress and Mickey ears brought back the memory of their first meeting.
“It made me emotional because social media connected us and now she’s a part of my wedding party,” Church says.
More Than One Themed Night

The “dress how you met the bride” party was only one part of the bachelorette weekend.
The group also held a “golden hour glam” night and a “sequins and seashells” celebration. Between the themed events, the women spent time talking, dancing, laughing, and remembering years of friendship.
Church also brought music into the weekend. As a singer, she naturally became part of the karaoke sessions.
“As a singer, I couldn’t get away with not doing karaoke and that was a highlight for me!” she says.
Church says the group “laughed till our cheeks hurt,” danced, reminisced about their years together, and enjoyed time without focusing on the wedding plans.
A Celebration of Long Friendships
Church says her friendships “have evolved and changed over the years,” but each woman still made time to celebrate her upcoming marriage. The weekend gave her a chance to appreciate the people who have remained part of her life through different stages.
“Seeing all my friends from different chapters of my life in one room was so special and made me feel so grateful and blessed to have people that I can have fun with in any season,” Church says.
She also reflected on the support she has received from her friends.
“They have all been there for me through my best and worst moments, but celebrating getting married to the love of my life is the most special one so far and that’s when the emotions really hit me!”
With the November wedding approaching, Church is looking forward to married life while keeping those long-standing friendships close.
“As I enter this next chapter excited to begin married life I will continue to hold onto these friendships and look forward to making more memories in the future with them — we haven’t told our husbands yet but this may have to be a yearly girls trip!”